Most companies understand the risk of losing experienced leaders.

Far fewer understand the second problem that follows.

What happens after they leave and you realize they took decades of judgment, instinct, customer knowledge, operational shortcuts, and problem-solving ability with them?

At that point, most organizations scramble.

Are there any SOPs? Does anyone remember “how Bob used to handle this?” They attempt to reconstruct tribal knowledge after the person who held it is already gone.

Sadly, it’s too late.

This is one of the most common succession planning mistakes I see in organizations of every size. Companies assume knowledge transfer means documentation. They create binders, process maps, checklists, or video tutorials and believe the problem is solved.

But leadership knowledge not just just procedural.

Experienced leaders have context. Judgment. Pattern recognition. Political awareness. Relationship history. The ability to spot problems before others even know there is a problem. That kind of wisdom is difficult to capture in a spreadsheet.

So what do you do if you missed the window?

One surprisingly effective strategy is to bring retired or departing leaders back in a completely different role:
As coaches for the younger, less experienced staff.

How to make this work: Give the retirees some training in coaching skills (this is very important; coaching is a very specific technique that is easy to implement once you know the process) and then deploy them intentionally throughout the organization — on job sites, in departments, during operational meetings, and alongside younger employees.

Because these retirees have only one job – to coach – the upleveling of skills is fast and on-poing.  Younger employees do not just need answers. They need exposure to experienced thinking.

A seasoned operations leader walking a job site with a younger supervisor can point out issues that no training manual would ever teach. An experienced executive observing a new manager conducting a staff meeting can help them understand body language, timing, and leadership during a debrief conversation.

And because these experienced leaders are not “the boss,” employees often respond differently to them. The coaches can observe, correct, guide, mentor, and champion employees without triggering the tension that sometimes comes when formal authority walks into the room. Instead of “Uh oh, here comes the boss,” the interaction becomes collaborative and developmental.

That kind of development accelerates growth dramatically.

A small engineering firm we worked with had a retired engineer come in just one day a week to be a resources for the younger engineers. He would review their work, offer suggestions, help them practice presentations, and challenge them when he knew they were ready to move to the next level of their work.

Former leaders often thrive in these roles because they no longer carry the daily operational burden. They are freer to observe, teach, ask questions, and help others think critically rather than simply solving problems for them.

Most organizations have not thought creatively enough about this talent pool yet.

And there is another hidden benefit:
It preserves culture.

When experienced leaders disappear abruptly, organizations often lose not just knowledge, but leadership behaviors, decision-making norms, and institutional values. Coaching relationships allow those behaviors to continue spreading through the organization long after the formal leadership transition occurs.

Of course, this approach only works if companies are intentional.

Not every great operator is naturally a good coach. Coaching requires listening, patience, curiosity, and the ability to guide rather than direct. That is why formal coaching training matters so much.

When done well, this can become one of the most powerful leadership development tools a company has.

Succession planning is not just about replacing positions; it is about transferring knowledge, experience and skill before it’s too late.

By Nanette Miner, Ed.D.

Keywords: Entrepreneurship, HR, Leadership

Follow Us On

Become a Contributor Newsletter Signup