Nov18
Two cars come off the same assembly line in South Carolina, built on the same platform and reportedly running the same software. Starting with model year 2027, one can continue being sold in the United States. The other cannot.
The Volvo EX90 and Polestar 3 are manufactured at Volvo's South Carolina plant, and both companies are owned by China's Geely Holding. In May 2026, the U.S. Commerce Department authorized Volvo to continue selling their vehicles in the United States. A month later, Polestar received the opposite decision.
The difference comes down to the Commerce Department's Connected Vehicle Rule, which restricts Chinese and Russian technology in vehicles capable of communicating with outside networks. The regulation covers nearly every new passenger vehicle sold in the U.S., with software restrictions beginning in model year 2027 and hardware restrictions following in 2030.
The rule reaches beyond where a vehicle is manufactured. It considers whether a company or component is owned by, controlled by, or subject to the jurisdiction of China or Russia. A manufacturer controlled by either country can be prohibited from selling connected vehicles in the U.S., regardless of where those vehicles are assembled.
That creates a difficult problem for automakers with complex international ownership structures. Polestar has already discontinued sales of its China-built Polestar 2 in the U.S. and manufactures the Polestar 3 in South Carolina and the Polestar 4 in South Korea. Moving production outside China, however, does nothing to change its ownership.
Volvo faces similar ownership questions, yet received approval. The Commerce Department has declined to explain the difference, and the regulation explicitly states that individual authorization decisions will not be made public.
Volvo CEO Håkan Samuelsson has suggested that data security played an important role, saying the company demonstrated how it would protect information collected by connected vehicles. Polestar's U.S. head of government affairs, Peter Wexler, has said the company is still trying to understand why its application was denied.
The uncertainty extends beyond these two manufacturers.
Ford's Lincoln Nautilus, which is manufactured in China, initially appeared to face the same restrictions. Although Ford develops their software in the United States, that software is installed in China. Ford requested authorization in June, but by August, the company said discussions with Commerce had established that authorization was no longer necessary.
Ford has also announced plans to move some Lincoln production to the United States beginning in 2030. CEO Jim Farley cited the Connected Vehicle Rule and tariffs as factors, although the 52.5 percent tariff on the Nautilus was the primary consideration.
Meanwhile, Congress is considering legislation that could make the restrictions more permanent and significantly less flexible.
The proposed Connected Vehicle Security Act would prohibit automakers with more than 15 percent Chinese ownership from selling connected vehicles in the U.S. That threshold could affect Mercedes-Benz, whose Chinese investors collectively exceed the proposed limit. The bill stalled in the Senate on September 30, but could return after the November elections.
For procurement and supply chain leaders, the implications extend far beyond automotive manufacturing. Supplier due diligence increasingly requires understanding corporate ownership and control, alongside the origins of physical components. Software provenance introduces another challenge, requiring visibility into who developed code, where it was installed, and who maintains it.
The approaching 2030 hardware deadline will make those questions even more consequential as manufacturers confront the possibility of replacing physical components across established supply networks.
Volvo and Polestar demonstrate how difficult compliance becomes when seemingly identical products receive different regulatory treatment. Both companies can manufacture vehicles in South Carolina, but neither can easily change who owns them.
And when ownership can determine market access, knowing where a product was made may no longer be enough.
Listen to the full episode of Art of Supply here: https://artofprocurement.com/blog/supply-why-volvo-can-keep-selling-cars-in-the-u.s.-and-polestar-cant
Sources:
https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/senate-bill/4429
By Kelly Barner
Keywords: Manufacturing, Supply Chain, Transportation
Knowing Where a Product Was Made Is No Longer Enough
Who Owns the Idea When AI Writes the Pitch?
The Cascading Cyber Crisis: When AI-Accelerated Attacks and Digital Failures Threaten Our Connected World
Sua empresa tem processos que geram valor ou apenas fluxogramas bem desenhados?
Coaching that raises capability compounds results beyond your span