10 Questions I Get the Most About Succession Planning (With Answers)

After years of advising privately held companies, I’ve noticed something interesting:

The questions don’t really change.

Different industries. Different sizes. Different personalities.
But the same concerns come up again and again.

If you’re wondering where to start—or whether you’re doing this “right”—you’re not alone.

Here are the 10 questions I get most often, and the answers leaders actually need.

1. Where do we even start?

Start with data—not diagrams.

Before you build anything, you need to understand:

• What your key roles are
• Where your biggest people risks sit
• Who is “ready now” vs. “ready with development”

Most companies skip this and jump straight to filling in roles and names on a chart. That generally leads to a lot of mis-starts.

2. How long does succession planning take?

Longer than you want (or thought it would).

Developing a true successor takes years—not months.
If your timeline is 12–18 months, you’re not building organizational capability and leadership readiness—you’re plugging leaks.

A reasonable time-horizon is 3 years, a better timeline is 5–10 years in order to build real depth across the organization.

3. What if we don’t have anyone ready?

That’s more common than you think.

But now you’ve identified the risk—which is progress.

From there, you have two options:

• Build internally (if you have time)
• Define what “right” looks like so you can recruit externally (if you don’t have time)

What you don’t want to do is set someone up to fail by pretending their ready when they’re not.

4. Isn’t this HR’s responsibility?

No.

HR can drive the process, organize the data, and keep things moving.
But succession planning is a leadership responsibility.

If the CEO and executive team don’t own it and champion it, it won’t stick.

5. How do we identify high-potential employees?

Carefully.

High performance ≠ high potential.

Look for:

• Ability to think beyond their function
• Willingness to take on ambiguity and risk
• Capacity to lead others, not just do the work

And most importantly—interest. Believe it or not, not everyone aspires to lead at the highest levels.

6. Why don’t we just hire from the outside?

Sometimes you have to.

External hires can bring new capabilities—especially in areas like technology or scaling operations.

But they also introduce risk:

• Cultural misalignment
• Lack of internal credibility
• Disruption to your existing team

If you go external, be very clear about what you need in terms of skill and personality—and what you can’t afford to compromise.

7. What roles should we focus on first?

CEO succession matters. But so do the roles that keep the business running day-to-day.

Ask yourself:

• What roles would create immediate disruption if vacant?
• Where is knowledge concentrated in one person?

That’s where you start.

8. How do we know if someone is ready?

Have you been purposefully building their knowledge, skills and capabilities?

Readiness comes from exposure to:

• Enterprise-level decision-making
• High-stakes situations
• Accountability for outcomes beyond their function

If they haven’t had those experiences, they’re not ready yet.

9. How do we develop future leaders?

Through experience—not just training.

Courses, coaching, and mentoring help. But they don’t replace real responsibility.

The fastest way to grow leaders is through:

• Stretch assignments
• Cross-functional exposure
• Ownership of meaningful outcomes

Development happens in the work—not outside of it.  quote card goes here

10. What’s the biggest mistake companies make?

Treating succession planning like a one-time event.

It’s not something you “do” once and check off the list.

It’s a system.

The companies that do this well are constantly:

• Assessing risk
• Developing people
• Adjusting based on business needs

They don’t wait for a retirement or resignation to start paying attention.

One Final Thought

Succession planning isn’t about having all the answers.

It’s about asking better questions—and being honest about what you find.

Because the goal isn’t to create a perfect plan.

It’s to build a business that can keep moving forward… no matter who’s in the role.

By Nanette Miner, Ed.D.

Keywords: Entrepreneurship, HR, Leadership

Follow Us On

Become a Contributor Newsletter Signup